![]() |
Not Guilty: Andrew Saupe |
Andrew Saupe, 44, who has over two decades service in the British Army, found himself charged with GBH after being manhandled to the station floor in the early hours.
He was found not guilty at City of London Magistrates Court of inflicting grievous bodily harm on PC Luca Amante - who has not returned to active duty - on July 8, last year.
Saupe, of Watertower Way, Basingstoke told the one-day trial the British Transport Police officer’s ankle snapped due to the policeman’s own aggressive behaviour.
The officer had grabbed Saupe by the arm seconds earlier and admits he attempted to take the chef to the station floor, but ended up screaming in agony and needing surgery, plus a plate and six pins to his ankle.
Saupe had sprinted to the station from The Gherkin building, where his works all-day Summer Party had concluded, during which he consumed ten bottles of beer.
“I’d say I was tipsy, not drunk. Ten bottles with my military and chef experience is light drinking really,” he told the trial.
![]() |
Broken Ankle: PC Luca Amante with PCSO Philip Morgan |
“Where is my train? Where can I stay safe in London? I once tried to walk home and it took me two hours to get to Clapham and I did not want to be walking the streets of London.
“I felt threatened by PC Amante, his body language, his facial movements, his rolling of the eyes,” said Saupe, the ex-Head Chef of the British Academy on The Mall.
Another officer and PCSO Philip Morgan struggled to convince Saupe his last train had departed and there was little they could do for him before eventually getting him moving.
“I was feeling threatened and took a step or two backwards because PC Amante is charging towards me. He grabbed my right arm and pulled me forward and the other policeman grabbed my left arm.
“We have tumbled forwards and gone down and PC Amante grabbed my neck with both hands and pulled me on to top him. I then heard him screaming out in pain.
“I think the injury was caused by him grabbing me.
“I did not want to be grabbed by this person. He charged towards me and grabbed me in an aggressive manner, but I am a twenty-four year soldier and if I am grabbed I am going to get them away.
“I was being grabbed hold of left right and centre and was struggling to speak because someone was around my voice box.”
Earlier PC Amante, a former prison officer, told the trial: “He was required to leave and we tried to persuade him to leave the station and he eventually agreed to go to reception.
“He was quite upset with me for whatever reason, saying I was disrespectful to him and he said that I should not follow him.
“The gentleman was very upset, speaking loudly was very argumentative and coming across in a very unpredictable way.
“I walked towards him to take his right arm to eject him from the station and at that point he tried to punch me in the face.”
PCSO Morgan’s body-worn camera captured the entire incident and there was no obvious evidence of an attempted blow delivered by Saupe.
“I tried to throw him on the floor and fell and he rugby-tackled me and my legs went under and with his weight and my bodyweight my left ankle snapped and was broken in two places.
“He was on to top of me and I felt the crack in my ankle. The pain was instant.”
The body-worn footage captured PC Amante screaming: “My ankle!” and Saupe dismissively responding: “I’ve not touched his ankle. He is playing up like a footballer.”
The officer was keen to tell the trial he was down £3,000 due to lost overtime and dog-walker costs and spent twenty days at home on painkillers before surgery, plus a lengthy recovery period.
“Since this happened I have been in constant pain and I am still restricted to desk duty. I may need another surgery and have ligament damage.
“I cannot run and cannot have any impact on my foot and I do not know if I will ever return to duty.”
When questioned by police Saupe said his military career, which included duty in Northern Ireland; Kosovo; Iraq and Germany, left him with PTSD.
He hoped the station or train company would provide him with accommodation for the night or an alternative way to get home.
Saupe told the trial his military background and mental health issues resulted in his “fight or flight” behaviour that night.
“I am sorry his ankle was broken, but I do not feel it was caused by my actions.”